Data, Data everywhere, Nor Any Drop to Drink: The Case for the Joint Integrator
Andrew Kirby1 and Jeremy Stredwick2
1Australian Defence College
2Arc Professional Services
The Australian government has made very clear that, to defend the nation, the Australian Defence Force (ADF) must be an integrated force. This article contends that such a goal remains an unrealised ambition. The 2023 Defence Strategic Review (DSR) (Houston & Smith, 2023), described as ‘one of the greatest shifts in Australia's military since WWII’, sets out integration as one of the most critical objectives for the ADF (Evans, 2023). The DSR states that deterrence, denial and response must be built on ‘…a genuine Integrated Force which harnesses effects across all five domains: maritime, land, air, space and cyber’ (Houston & Smith, 2023). In translating the DSR’s recommendations into action, the National Defence Strategy (NDS) elevated this goal into ‘national defence’, i.e. harnessing ‘all arms of Australia’s national power to establish a holistic, integrated and focused approach to protect our security and advance our interests (Australian Government, 2024)’.
This article analyses the significant challenges faced in integrating the force, most notably the question of who is actually doing the integration.
The Problem
Defence has become a prodigious creator of data in recent years, a trend which will only accelerate. On one hand, this is a positive development as it reflects the growth of high quality, highly connected sensors that Defence is investing. However, the profusion of sensing capability will challenge Defence’s existing sense-making capability through a deluge of data. Over the next few years, Defence will have added to its inventory Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance (ISR) platforms such as the MC-55 Peregrine, Land 129 Phase 3’s Integrator platform, MQ-4C Triton, P8 Poseidon, multiple geospatial capabilities and completely new air and space domain awareness capabilities. This raises critical questions about joint data integration.
For instance, can data from the P-8 Poseidon be shared with the Army? How is an Army amphibious task force sharing its Battle Management System data with the Navy’s Combat Management System? And can space domain awareness data be integrated with a Joint Task Force while underway? Under Defence’s matrixed approach, each program mentioned above has a designated capability manager. With different capability managers spread across an array of projects and programs, there needs to be someone ultimately responsible for data integration.
Defence has numerous policy – and paper – based organisations, but very few are dedicated to execution (those who actually operationalise the data and are hands-on with the 1’s and 0’s). The challenge is not only technical but organisational, and calls for establishing clear roles and responsibilities for data integration across different domains and branches of the military. Effective integration requires coordinated efforts and streamlined processes to ensure critical information flows seamlessly between platforms, enhancing situational awareness and operational effectiveness.
The current approach
Defence has a number of organisations with ‘integration’ in their title. However, it is not clear that any one of them is addressing the enterprise problem. At the strategic centre, there is the Force Integration Division (Australian Government, n.d.a). Force Integration Division is not a technical delivery group. It does not own or control networks as per Defence Digital Group, and their role stops largely at analysis and advice. At the other extreme sits Army’s Land Network Integration Centre, which has demonstrated a significant ability to integrate systems, but as an Army’s network ingestion organisation it does not control the networks for other services or Joint systems, bearers or standards to integrate Defence’s proliferating data systems (Robards, 2024; Australian Army, n.d.).
In August 2021, Defence announced the creation of the Chief Data Integration Officer (CDIO), whose role within Data Division reports directly to the Department of Defence Diarchy to provide advice and guidance (Hastie, 2021; Hendry, 2021). The Capability Acquisition and Sustainment Group (CASG) recently migrated its integration area, but again, it was a governance and policy-based group and not focused on execution.
Defence Digital Group, formerly known as Chief Information Officer Group, which owns the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) Defence corporate networks has a role in Defence mission systems, but only when they want to connect to the corporate network (Australian Government, n.d.b). They also aren't necessarily the group responsible for data storage nor the data integrator. CASG’s Tactical Data Link Bureau manages some joint data links, but only some and not bulk ISR data.
Defence’s recent Digital Engineering Strategy 2024 is another weighty tome but light on guidance as to who is responsible for the actual conduct of joint integration of the digital engineering. The conceptual digital engineering capability lifecycle model presented in Appendix A of the strategy has the least amount of detail in the “in-service” column, where, in reality, it is where the rubber meets the road. (Department of Defence, 2024)
Put simply, in the Defence organisation, it is confusing where the boundaries lie and who is responsible for doing the work to create a “genuine Integrated Force”. It does appear that there is no data integration agency whose job it is to store bulk ISR data, convert data feeds, and connect it to capability elements. It also begs the question as to how many policy and governance organisations can provide robust advice without in-house expertise. Advice and guidance about data without real-world data experience is fraught with danger.
As an example, Air Force acquires a fleet of ISR aircraft, with each platform containing 40 systems. Each of these is an ICT system in its own right with proprietary software, firmware and its own data needs. The fleet is acquired off the shelf from the United States (US) as a foreign military sales (FMS) acquisition, meaning Australia has not built it, nor do we have the technical workforce to do so. Inevitably, this fleet will be part of a spiral upgrade program with its original manufacturer, during which most of the sensor systems will upgrade to newer versions. This creates an exponential integration problem as the first platform will be running new systems than the older platforms. Air Force will be responsible for ensuring integration in its own air domain – something that the report by the Australian National Audit Office into the unlamented Tiger helicopter notes is often incredibly difficult (Hehir, 2016). Who, then, is undertaking joint integration as this spiral of spirals continues?
Current project-based approaches can exacerbate silos by their very design of individual projects to solve their problems individually. Defence had at least three geospatial projects, one for the Navy, Army, and Air Force, where each service had “unique” needs respective to their service. They were each allocated funds in the Integrated Investment Program (IPP), but that spend was allocated in silos to each project. Each individual project would not risk affecting its own schedule by collaborating with another service doing very much the same thing with the same data. Defence needs to ensure its systems can interoperate not just with each other but also with all types of allies, domestic, foreign, sophisticated and unsophisticated, classified and unclassified.
The US Air Force have recently appreciated this problem and have pledged to stand up an Integrated Command Capabilities by the end of this year in an attempt to keep up with the modernisation efforts and tempo of modern warfare (Easley, 2024).
A better way
The NDS proposes that Defence capability needs to be conceived across three epochs (Australian Government, 2024, p. 28):
now to 2025: the Enhanced Force-in-Being will focus on immediate enhancements that can be made to the current force.
2026 to 2030: the Objective Integrated Force will see the accelerated acquisition of critical capabilities.
2031 and beyond: the Future Integrated Force will see the delivery of an ADF that is fit for purpose across all domains and enablers.
Noting that “integration” initiatives appear to start in 2026, what then is to be done? To increase Defence’s integration—rather than drown in the data it is set to generate—structural governance and procedural reform are required.
Defence would benefit from an enterprise-wide approach akin to the Land Network Integration Centre, a Joint Network Integration Centre (JNIC). This hands-on group's remit would be to bring together disparate information feeds and create common repositories at all classifications. As well as ensuring Defence gains skills and knowledge to deliver integration, it would also ensure that policy and governance are grounded in evidence and knowledge. A JNIC would be responsible for implementing standards and policies from the CDIO in the Data Division and the architectural patterns of the Force Integration Division at the Integrated Force level via networks handled by the Defence Digital Group.
Data must be handled and managed according to the Archives Act 1983 (Cth). That means data custodians must ensure end-to-end data providence, where data can be tracked and traced from generation to archival. A key aspect of this policy is boundary points, such as once data has been generated by a sensor platform, there is a transfer of custodianship from the collector to the point of aggregation.
Murphy’s Law tells us that battles are always fought at the edges of maps, a problem which can be overcome by extending with more maps using sticky tape. But when our future battles occur at the edges of our data, whose job is it to sticky tape more data?
Comments
REVIEW ON INSTANT LOVE SPELL THAT BROUGHT MY EX BACK TO ME IN L
REVIEW ON INSTANT LOVE SPELL THAT BROUGHT MY EX BACK TO ME IN LESS THAN 24 HOURS CONTACT HIM NOW AND EXPERIENCE HIS POWERFUL SPELL ON WHATSAPP +447477869404.USA, UK, FRANCE, CANADA, AUSTRALIA, NETHERLANDS, AUSTRIA, BELGIUM, IRELAND.
My name is Rhiannon Van Ross, and I want to share my story with you. Earlier this year, I found myself in the midst of a bitter divorce battle with my husband. He had an affair with a co-worker and repeatedly lied to me, making me feel like a fool for suspecting his infidelity. He claimed he was no longer in love with me and demanded a divorce. I was devastated. I couldn't believe that the man I loved with all my heart could do this to me. I read the messages they sent to each other, and those words are forever burned into my mind. Every day, I woke up wondering how I got there, what went wrong, and why this was happening to me. I knew I had to take action and put an end to the pain he was causing me. That's when I remembered Dr. Saruman Spell Temple, a Love Spell Temple I saw in Florida last year near Orlando. I didn't know how it worked, but I was desperate for a solution. I contacted Dr. Saruman and ordered an instant love spell that works. I was skeptical at first, but I was willing to try anything to save my marriage. To my surprise, the love spell worked like magic! My husband started showing me affection again, and he apologized for everything he did. He even ended his affair and begged for my forgiveness. I am forever grateful to Dr. Saruman for his incredible work. He helped me save my marriage and gave me hope for the future. If you're going through a similar situation, I highly recommend Dr. Saruman Spell Temple. His love spells are powerful and effective, and he truly cares about his client's happiness. Don't suffer in silence. Take action and get the help you need to save your relationship. Contact Dr. Saruman today directly on his WhatsApp "+447477869404" and see for yourself how his love spells can change your life for the better.
*LOVE SPELLS
*MARRIAGE SPELLS
*MONEY SPELLS
*BEAUTY SPELLS
*WEALTH SPELLS
*ATTRACTION SPELLS
*HIV CURE SPELLS
*CASINO SPELLS
*REMOVE CURSE SPELLS
*PROTECTION SPELLS
*LOTTERY SPELLS
*GOOD LUCK SPELLS
*FERTILITY SPELLS
top-quality Ugandan robusta and Arabica coffee +27719755564
Looking for top-quality Ugandan robusta and Arabica coffee beans? Contact +27719755564. Bold, flavorful, and perfect for roasting and retail. Wholesale inquiries welcome – let’s do business!" WhatsApp+27719755564,email,paullubega412@gmail.com
REAL LOST LOVE SPELLS CASTER IN USA+27717403094
With my experience working with Abdul Basser, i came to the conclusion there are very good and honest people out there who can truly do all they can to fix whatever problems you have even when they are not known to you visibly or see them in person. I lost my marriage for not being able to fully what it means to lead a woman right and accept the fact that they are wired in a way we men can never understand. I had to seek help from psychic medium Abdul Basser knowing my wife is a good woman whom i cant loose to anyone else. It was a tough situation for me though and too many things was revealed to me while he was helping me to fix the probleems and i got the effect of the result just after 48 hours as he assured me and i have my wife back home to me. Abdul Basser is the best option you can choose to restore love and connection between you and your partner and get back them back to your lives and be happy together forever. You can call/text him via WhatsApp +27717403094 or click on his webpage and see more details about his good works. https://africanancientspells.mystrikingly.com/
https://uaeplusplus.com//pages/registerNew/companyRegistered.aspx?ID=zh…
https://streamable.com/41l6w0
Love Spells to Bring Ex Back Today+27785149508
I’m thrilled to share my incredible experience with psychic medium Ibrahim, a powerful psychic medium Ibrahim who helped me reunite with my wife. We were facing numerous issues, and our relationship deteriorated, leading to a heartbreaking breakup. However, with the guidance of psychic medium Ibrahim, whom my friend introduced me to, I followed his advice and, amazingly, my wife returned to me within 24 hours! I’m forever grateful. For those seeking help, you can reach psychic medium Ibrahim at profibrahim98@gmail.com or WhatsApp him on +27785149508 /
Email:profibrahim98@gmail.com
https://africanspellcaster.mystrikingly.com
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/s1ewUeVVAHk
powerfulspellcastertraditionalhealer27785149508197.home.blog
https://write.as/ibra/
https://rumble.com/v6uozw1-connecting-with-affordable-psychics-what-you…
https://photos.google.com/album/AF1QipOW2O3Qs4DZ8RHkSGMVeW7qCgxM5zPbPni…
for quick results.
LOTTERY SPELL THAT WORKS INSTANTLY WITH THE HELP OF A SPELL CAST
Imagine becoming vastly wealthy overnight. Being a winner of a multi-million-dollar lottery is certainly a life-changing event for almost every single lottery winner. My name is Laura Benson from Chicopee, Massachusetts, the famous PowerBall lottery winner of $758 million (£591m) in 2017. I know many people would wonder how I had won the lottery. Would you believe me if I told you that I did it with spell casting? I met this famous spell caster known as Dr Isa, and he was the one who did it for me. As shocking as it was to me, I also want to encourage all those who need help to try their luck with Dr. Isa, who helped me win the lottery. I believe you’re still going to win with his help, too, just like he did for me. WhatsApp: +2347046030096 Email: > drisaspellcaster@gmail.com
Website: https://drisaspellcaster.wixsite.com/dr-isa
ex back
I really want to thank Dr Emu for saving my marriage. My wife really treated me badly and left home for almost 3 month this got me sick and confused. Then I told my friend about how my wife has changed towards me. Then she told me to contact Dr Emu that he will help me bring back my wife and change her back to a good woman. I never believed in all this but I gave it a try. Dr Emu casted a spell of return of love on her, and my wife came back home for forgiveness and today we are happy again. If you are going through any relationship stress or you want back your Ex or Divorce husband you can contact his email emutemple@gmail.com or WhatsApp +2348071657174
Https://web.facebook.com/Emu-Temple-104891335203341
POWERFUL SPELL CASTER WHO CAN HELP YOU WITH A LOVE SPELL TO GET
POWERFUL SPELL CASTER WHO CAN HELP YOU WITH A LOVE SPELL TO GET YOUR EX-LOVER BACK URGENTLY AFTER BREAKUP/DIVORCE EVEN IF YOUR SITUATION SEEMS HOPELESS! CONTACT DR SARUMAN: WHATSAPP: +447477869404 OR EMAIL: PERFECTSOLUTIONTEMPLES@GMAIL.COM DR SARUMAN IS CERTAINLY THE BEST SPELL CASTER AND HIS RESULT IS 100% GUARANTEED.
Allow me to present my testimony, My name is Mylene Sint Jago and I hail from Curacao. I am here to share with you an extraordinary experience I had with DR. SARUMAN. My husband and I had been married for seven years and were blessed with two adorable children, a boy, and a girl. However, our happiness came under threat when my husband's behavior suddenly changed. He started coming home late from work, and his attention towards me and the kids dwindled significantly. It wasn't long before I discovered that he was seeing someone else. I tried to fix our marriage, but my efforts were fruitless, and I became increasingly worried and desperate for a solution. One day, while browsing the internet, I stumbled upon a website that recommended DR. SARUMAN https://perfectsolutiontemple.weebly.com as a solution to marital problems and relationship issues. Intrigued, I decided to give him a chance and contacted him for help. To my surprise, he responded promptly and performed a powerful spell for me. To my amazement, just two days later, my husband came to me and apologized for his wrongdoings. He promised to never leave us again, and ever since then, our family has been reunited, and our lives have been filled with happiness and love. I cannot express my gratitude enough to DR. SARUMAN for his intervention in saving my marriage. If you or anyone you know is facing similar challenges in their relationship, I implore you not to ignore this message. DR. SARUMAN has the power to restore broken relationships and bring joy and fulfillment back into your life, Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61560420964460&sk=about&viewas=… Youtube Link: https://youtu.be/RrlR858dhtg Youtube Email: perfectsolutiontemples@gmail.com or you can chat him directly on his WhatsApp: +447477869404. I would advise you to contact DR SARUMAN because he is the right man to help you get all your spiritual problem solved with his powerful spell.
*LOVE SPELLS
*MARRIAGE SPELLS
*MONEY SPELLS
*BEAUTY SPELLS
*WEALTH SPELLS
*ATTRACTION SPELLS
*HIV CURE SPELLS
*CASINO SPELLS
*REMOVE CURSE SPELLS
*PROTECTION SPELLS
*LOTTERY SPELLS
*GOOD LUCK SPELLS
*FERTILITY SPELLS
DR UYI HELP ME WIN LOTTERY ALL THANKS TO YOU DR UYI
I had to write back and say what an amazing experience I had with Dr Uyi for his powerful lottery spell. My Heart is filled with joy and happiness after he cast the Lottery spell for me, And i won $750,000,000 His spell changed my life into riches, I’m now out of debts and experiencing the most amazing good luck with the lottery after I won a huge amount of money. My life has really changed for good. I won (seventy five thousand dollars)Your Lottery spell is so real and pure. Thank you very much for the lottery spell that changed my life” I am totally grateful for the lottery spell you did for me Dr Uyi and i say i will continue to spread your name all over so people can see what kind of man you are. Anyone in need of help can email Dr Uyi for your own lottery number, because this is the only secret to winning the lottery. Email: drzukalottospelltemple@gmail.com OR WhatsApp on +17174154115
MY HEART IS FULL OF GRATITUDE OF WHAT DR UYI DID FOR ME BY HELPI
It’s an honor to share this testimony to the world. Dr UYI you're a blessing to our generation. I have always desired to win lottery some day, at some point I thought it was something impossible, until I came across series of testimonies on how had helped a lot of people win lottery, at first I was so skeptical about it because I haven't seen a things as such in my life, at a second thought I decided to give it a try so I emailed him via his person email, he replied me and instructed me on what to do, after 24 hours he gave me some numbers and I won $2 million just like that. Dr UYI I owe everything for making me the man that I am right. If you need his help below is his contact information, he can help too Email: drzukalottospelltemple@gmail.com OR WhatsApp on +17174154115
The wonderful works of Dr Isikolo
The marital crisis I was going through came to and end when Dr Isikolo got involved. Just like every other couples out there, we had our differences and I ensure I did my best to lead her right, provide for her and my kids and also protected them. We both made sacrifices to ensure we survived the union until she started acting up and deliberately had so many fights with me. The home became unpleasant for everyone else including my children. She was being manipulated by a friend who had been divorced and wanted to also ruin my marriage. I had to contact Dr Isikolo and he responded and did his best to end the issues. He restored the love and connection between us and I can tell now that whatever illusion my wife was under has been taking away and she is a better woman now. The result of what Dr Isikolo did for me that manifested after two days was what amazed me. I and my household remain grateful. I appeal to anyone who needs help to fix their relationships and marital problems to contact Dr Isikolo because the solution is sure. His webpage: https://isikolo-temple.com or text him on WhatsApp +2348133261196
love spells by dr isikolo
I almost lost my marriage when I watched my wife turned into a total stranger and left the kids and I. I was so furious knowing I had done everything possible to ensure I sustained my marriage as a father and husband. The terrible fights we had traumatized me and I couldn’t function properly as a man. I kept on trying to find out what made her did what she did which made me contacted Dr Isikolo. I was surprised to have found out that she was under a huge manipulation from a man who wanted to ruin my marriage with her and take her away from me. Dr Isikolo had to intervene and fixed the problem thereby ensuring she was rescued from the claws of the dark magic charm they used on her. Knowing that I was able to get my family together again with the help of Dr Isikolo gives me joy and I am forever thankful to him. His page: https://isikolo-temple.com or text him on WhatsApp via +2348133261196
THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT // THE BEST RECOVERY EXPERTS
THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT // THE BEST RECOVERY EXPERTS
I cannot express enough gratitude for THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. They are truly the leading experts in the field and deserve every bit of praise for recovering cryptocurrency wallets when all hope seems lost. Thanks to their intervention, I can finally reclaim peace of mind and focus on rebuilding my financial future with renewed confidence. I highly recommend anyone in a similar situation, details below to get in touch with them right now.
web: https://thehackangels.com
Mail Box; support@thehackangels.com
Whatsapp; +1(520)-200,2320
love spells by dr isikolo
I gave it all i had to make it work in my marriage but he still left me and our kids. His family fought for me and still nothing changed and he left broken and sad. I manage to keep going on with the hope everything will get better for us one day and he will be back to you. He is a great father to the kids and i had great belief i will see him return back to us. I was lucky enough to got in contact with Dr Isikolo who indeed knew how to fix the problem and he did and to my surprise, my husband came back home to me. I am still amazed how it was possible but indeed this true. The result of his work is assured to manifest after 48 hours. My husband returned and i know better Dr Isikolo is truly a honest man anyone can trust. He is good in his job of fixing problems between partner and have them get back together again. You can read about his works on his page: https://isikolo-temple.com, or might as well text him via WhatsApp on: +2348133261196.
The wonderful works of Dr Isikolo
I have had my fair share of emotional traumas and failed relationships. There is nothing more to life than staying hopeful even when we expect the worse. I was lucky once more when i met my fiancé and he was all that i ever wanted in a man. I was always treated right by him and i had always believed we are ending up together. Unknown to me that devil had struck even before my wishes came through. He was taken from me by another bitch and it was hell for me knowing he had left me. I was so sure that he didn't do so with his clear mind because everything seems award when it occurred. So i had to look for help and I found dr isikolo who revealed to me that my man was hypnotized with charms by the said lady. He worked for me and got my man back to me and now we are back again. I cant be thankful enough knowing everything Dr isikolo promised was fulfilled and knowing the result of his works manifests after 48 hours. No lies about all you will ever hear about him and what he does. Contact him now if need be and be fully assured he wont fail you. Text him on WhatsApp via +2348133261196, or visit his webpage: https://isikolo-temple.com
Add new comment